When a Carrier’s Safety Record Becomes Part of a Wrongful Death Case
Key Takeaways: A Conditional safety rating generally means the FMCSA found that a trucking company lacked adequate safety controls to follow federal safety rules. That gap could lead to problems with driver qualification, hours-of-service, drug testing, and maintenance. If that carrier’s truck killed your loved one, the rating does not prove fault by itself. But it may point to safety failures the company knew about, or should have known about, and failed to fix. The Texas Wrongful Death Act generally allows surviving spouses, children, and parents to seek damages such as lost earning capacity and mental anguish. Under Chapter 72 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, a trucking company can ask to split the trial into two phases, which may limit what carrier safety evidence the jury hears in the first phase. Texas generally allows only two years to file, and key data can be lost quickly, so families should act early.
A Conditional safety rating generally means federal regulators found that a trucking company did not have adequate safety controls in place. If an 18-wheeler run by that carrier caused a fatal truck crash in Houston, the rating may point investigators toward the failures that put a dangerous driver or truck on the road. It does not prove fault on its own, and whether a jury hears about it depends on the rules of evidence and the facts of the case. Still, it can be a strong starting point for showing that a trucking company knew, or should have known, about problems it failed to fix. Families who lose a spouse, parent, or child in a commercial truck crash face far more than grief. They often lose decades of income, household support, and future plans. Trucking companies and their insurers build their defense quickly, so acting early matters.
If a commercial truck killed someone you love and you believe the carrier’s safety failures played a role, the trial attorneys at Fibich, Leebron, Copeland & Briggs are ready to review what happened. Call 713-751-0025 or contact our Houston team today to discuss your family’s case confidentially.

How the FMCSA CSA Rating System Works
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) tracks carrier safety through two related but separate tools. The first is the formal safety rating, which comes from a compliance review (now often called an investigation) under 49 C.F.R. Part 385. The second is the Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) program, which uses the Safety Measurement System (SMS) to measure carriers in Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories (BASICs) based on inspection, violation, and crash data.
People often use "FMCSA CSA rating" for both tools, but the difference matters in a lawsuit. A BASIC measure is a snapshot of changing data, not a safety rating. A formal rating is an official finding reached after FMCSA investigators review a company’s records and operations. Both can be useful evidence, and both have limits. Congress restricted the use of certain SMS data, and courts differ on whether and how SMS scores may be used at trial.
The Three Formal Safety Ratings
Under 49 C.F.R. § 385.3, FMCSA may give a carrier one of three ratings:
- Satisfactory: The carrier has adequate safety controls in place.
- Conditional: The carrier lacks adequate safety controls to ensure compliance, and that gap could lead to violations.
- Unsatisfactory: The carrier’s controls are inadequate and have led to violations. This can lead to an order to stop operating.
A carrier with no rating is "unrated," which generally means FMCSA has not completed a compliance review. Unrated does not mean safe. Many carriers operate for years without a formal review.
Why a Conditional Rating Raises Red Flags
A Conditional rating generally lets a carrier keep operating despite known weaknesses. Those weaknesses often involve areas that cause fatal crashes, including driver qualification files, hours-of-service compliance, drug and alcohol testing, and truck maintenance. When a fatal crash follows FMCSA’s warning, attorneys may ask what the company did to fix these problems.
Texas Adds Its Own Layer of Carrier Oversight
Houston-based carriers may face state-level reviews, not just federal ones. Under Tex. Transp. Code § 644.155, the Texas Department of Public Safety (DPS) must run a compliance review and safety audit program similar to the federal program in 49 C.F.R. Part 385.
Texas also requires its trucking safety rules to match federal standards. Under Tex. Transp. Code § 644.051, the DPS director must adopt rules for safe operation of commercial motor vehicles consistent with federal rules. You can read the full text of Texas commercial vehicle safety law in Chapter 644 of the Transportation Code.
💡 Pro Tip: A carrier’s SMS profile can change as data updates or ages out. Ask your attorney to capture the carrier’s public safety data as close to the crash date as possible.
Building a Wrongful Death Claim Against a Trucking Company
Texas law gives certain surviving family members the right to bring a wrongful death claim when another party’s wrongful act, neglect, carelessness, unskillfulness, or default causes a death. The Texas Wrongful Death Act, Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 71.001 et seq., allows the surviving spouse, children, and parents to bring the claim. Siblings generally cannot. If no eligible family member files within three months of the death, the estate’s executor or administrator may generally bring it, unless all eligible family members ask that no claim be filed.
These cases are rarely about the driver alone. Depending on the facts, the motor carrier, the truck owner, a maintenance contractor, a freight broker, or a parts maker may also be liable. Damages may include lost earning capacity, lost household services, loss of companionship, and mental anguish. Texas’s proportionate responsibility rules may also reduce or bar recovery if the jury finds the deceased partly at fault.
Timing is critical. Texas generally sets a two-year deadline for wrongful death claims under Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003, usually running from the date of death. Exceptions are narrow. For practical next steps, read our guide on what to do after a fatal 18-wheeler crash.
How Texas Trial Rules Shape What a Jury Hears
In 2021, Texas changed how commercial truck crash trials work. Under Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 72.052, added by H.B. 19, the court must split the trial into two phases if a defendant properly asks. In phase one, the jury decides liability and compensatory damages. In phase two, it decides exemplary (punitive) damages, along with any claim requiring proof of the employer’s own negligence. The full text of Chapter 72 trial procedures is available from the Texas Legislature.
Families should expect the trucking company to request this split, because it can limit what the jury hears early. Under § 72.052(b), the defendant must file the motion by the later of 120 days after filing its original answer, or 30 days after the family files a pleading adding a new claim against that defendant.
Evidence Allowed in Phase One
Even in a split trial, some federal-compliance evidence can come in during phase one. Under § 72.054(c)(1), enacted by H.B. 19 in 2021, when the carrier is regulated under the Motor Carrier Safety Improvement Act of 1999 or Texas Transportation Code Chapter 644, either side may present evidence about whether the driver:
| Driver Issue | Related Federal Rule |
|---|---|
| Was licensed or disqualified | 49 C.F.R. 383.51, 383.52, 391.15 |
| Was medically certified | 49 C.F.R. 391.41 |
| Violated hours-of-service or drug and alcohol rules | 49 C.F.R. 382, 395 |
| Was under an out-of-service order | Federal and state OOS rules |
| Was texting or using a handheld phone | Federal distracted driving rules |
| Refused a required drug test in the prior two years | 49 C.F.R. 382 |
Section 72.054(c)(2) also allows phase-one evidence about the trucking company itself, including whether the company:
- Let the driver operate in violation of drug, alcohol, or hours-of-service rules
- Followed pre-employment drug testing rules, if the driver was impaired and the crash happened within 180 days of hire
- Made the background checks required by 49 C.F.R. 391.23(a), if the crash happened within a year of hire
- Was itself under an out-of-service order at the time of the crash
There is an important limit. Under § 72.054(d), the family may use this evidence in phase one only to prove ordinary negligent entrustment. Other proof of the carrier’s safety failures generally must wait until phase two.
Texas SB 39 (89th Legislature, 2025), which would have repealed § 72.054(c), (d), and (e) effective September 1, 2025, passed the Senate but died in the House Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence Committee and was never enacted into law. As a result, § 72.054(c), (d), and (e) remain in effect in Houston and throughout Texas, and the phase-one evidence carve-out for bifurcated commercial motor vehicle trials established by H.B. 19 in 2021 continues to apply.
Reaching the Carrier’s Broader Safety History
A phase-one finding against the driver may open the door to the company’s wider failures. Under § 72.052, if the jury finds the driver negligent, the case may move to phase two on claims against the employer such as negligent hiring, training, supervision, or retention, as well as exemplary damages. This is one way the problems behind a Conditional rating may reach the jury.
Turning an FMCSA CSA Rating Into Usable Evidence
A rating alone does not win a case, but the records behind it can be powerful. Compliance review reports, inspection histories, driver files, electronic logging device data, and maintenance records may show whether a carrier ignored warnings. An experienced FMCSA CSA rating lawyer can send preservation demands quickly, before data is erased or records go missing. Because FMCSA warns that SMS data has limits, attorneys generally tie any rating evidence to specific failures linked to the crash.
💡 Pro Tip: Companies may keep black box and electronic logging data for only a short time. A written letter sent early asking them to preserve it can help protect this evidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Does a Conditional rating prove the trucking company caused the crash?
No. It generally shows that FMCSA found inadequate safety controls at the time of review. Families must still prove that specific negligence caused the death.
2. Can a Conditional rating support a punitive damages claim?
It may. Texas generally requires clear and convincing evidence of gross negligence, malice, or fraud for exemplary damages, and caps usually apply. In a split trial, the jury decides those damages in phase two.
3. Who can file a wrongful death claim in Texas?
The surviving spouse, children, and parents may bring the claim. If none files within three months of the death, the estate’s representative may generally file it.
4. How long do we have to file?
Texas generally allows two years from the date of death under § 16.003. Exceptions are limited, so act promptly.
5. Does the state review Texas carriers too?
It may. Tex. Transp. Code § 644.155 requires DPS to run a compliance review and safety audit program for carriers based in Texas.
Holding Unsafe Carriers Accountable
A Conditional safety rating may show that regulators warned a trucking company about its safety failures before a fatal crash. Texas law shapes how that evidence is gathered and when a jury may hear it. Families who act early give their legal team a better chance to preserve key records and build a strong case.
If your family lost a loved one in a crash involving a commercial truck, Fibich, Leebron, Copeland & Briggs is prepared to take on the trucking company and its insurers. Call 713-751-0025 or schedule your confidential consultation to learn how Texas law may apply to your case.
Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is unique, and results may vary. Consult an attorney about your specific circumstances.